Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rwmj 4395 days ago
I wonder why they chose to use Intel NUC for this. It has dire price/performance. I built a cluster (see http://rwmj.wordpress.com/?s=cluster) recently, and I used AMD hardware for it because (as of right now) the performance is unbeatable for the price. I have a 32 core cluster that cost me £1300 including everything except a metal box to put it in.
2 comments
kapilvt 4395 days ago
That's pretty cool. One of the goals for the orangebox was being robust and compact enough to throw in a suitcase and fly to a conference. The nucs win on compactness, and also via intel's vpro/amt can do remote power management (ie. ipmi light).
link
rwmj 4395 days ago
Nice -- didn't know that Intel now had a serious remote management offering. These AMD mobos do wake-on-LAN, and that's it. They don't even have serial BIOS.
link
sparkiegeek 4395 days ago
To be honest, Intel's AMT is a bit of a PITA, but the Orange Boxes were assembled to have some resemblance to real racks of hardware. So remote out of band power control is essential.

There's something quite magical about using Juju and MAAS on the Orange Boxes and seeing the LEDs light up as you scale out a service (e.g. juju add-unit -n 5 nova-compute).

link
4ad 4395 days ago
Don't even have? Apart from Soekris and boards that can use Corerboot, what x86 board does?
link
bashinator 4395 days ago
Every single Supermicro and Tyan board I've ever used. Also every Dell, HP, and Sun/Oracle server I've ever used (though those can be a bit more of a pain). Really, anything with a halfway-decent IPMI implementation.
link
4ad 4393 days ago
We might be talking about different things. Soekris does this without IPMI.
link
bashinator 4388 days ago
The IPMI spec lets you send the entire console (BIOS through login boot cycle) out either the hardware serial port, or over a LAN for all those platforms.
link
rwmj 4395 days ago
I've just thrown away a 2007-era SuperMicro single U machine with serial BIOS.
link
4ad 4395 days ago
Nice to know that there are more machines like this.
link
jcastro 4395 days ago
Portability; from looking at your site you're using a standard ATX motherboard. The Orange Box is for demoing MAAS/OpenStack and needs to be portable enough to go on a plane.

Cool cluster btw, it'd be neat to see you blog about using MAAS on it.

link