Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by trhway 4404 days ago
it is lost on me why Skylon would be noticeably better than a Mach 5-6 plane boosting a second stage. Such 2 stage system would have obviously less trade-offs and thus would be easier/cheaper to design and build.
1 comments

Staging isn't free. While true that the second stage vehicle will be simpler, the combined second and first stage together could be more complicated/heavier than the Skylon.

Noticeably, the point of the Skylon and SABRE is that it's possible to use a common engine core in airbreathing and pure rocket mode, thus potentially generating weight savings.

I'm sure someone sat down and did the calculations. I have this feeling that a lot of the times when you actually sit down and work out the math for a range of assumptions, you generally come down to 'eh, maybe A, maybe B, so may as well try A'.