[twic]

Aha, yes, that makes sense. I don't think there's anything fundamentally wrong with packaging the app server along with the app. It's just not traditional in the Java world.

My preferred solution would be to package the app and the app server as operating system packages, and have the app depend on the app server. That makes the dependency explicit, but doesn't leave you with a gigantic deployable.

[jshen]

Here is one reason I like the bundled approach. I've been using golang recently which compiles into a machine executable. I was building a REST API that many third parties would use. When they wanted to use the API for development all I had to do was send them the bundle and tell them how to start. There were no other dependencies at all. It didn't assume a particular package manager, OS, or anything else. Take this file and execute it, that's it.