Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by _red 4420 days ago
No, NN won't fix the issue.

Even more, most NN supporters cannot actually state what they envision such laws to even do. If you ask, they will give you handwavy answers like "provide equal access"...then they will be unable / unwilling to answer any of the obvious questions that follow on from that (ie. what if I pay for faster access, what does that mean for others who don't? Is all QoS illegal now? How will NN be monitored, government installed monitoring stations in ISP? etc etc etc)

This is a political wet-dream though, lots of people clamoring for "more regulation" without any real knowledge of the details or effects. It was the same sort of lazy, unfocused clamor that brought us the Patriot Act, so be prepared.

1 comments

Here's my proposal:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7644339

It would fix the issues of neutrality at the interconnect point. Additional rules may be needed to prevent an ISP from throttling a specific port/protocol/service inside it's own network, but this would fix the current hot issue (blocking Youtube, Netflix, etc).