Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cwan 6143 days ago
I'm pretty sure that Taleb isn't a partisan - having also been pretty critical of Bush/Republicans (though he did point out the Obama administration's spending is magnitudes larger than his predecessor(s)). In the lead up to the crisis, Taleb was one of maybe only a couple people who not only forecasted the crisis but bet right on how it might occur. He used similarly dire language and was laughed at by many of his detractors. For this reason alone he shouldn't be so quickly dismissed.
1 comments

"For this reason alone he shouldn't be so quickly dismissed."

I'm not sure he'd agree with you. Taleb's books repeatedly stress the importance of survivorship bias. In any population, they'll be someone forecasting just about any conceivable event. No matter how unlikely events turn out to be, somebody is eventually going to be right, and then that person is lauded as a genius for having forecasted correctly. When really they've done no such thing; rather, people have just retrospectively picked out the person who happened to guess right.

I think Taleb would say you shouldn't dismiss him because there's ample evidence throughout history that he's right, not because he happened to guess right this time. Whenever debt levels have risen to what they are now, it's resulted in economic instability and chaotic behavior. It's not just this century: you can find examples back to Roman times.