[b0b_d0e]

Thats the rework that I'm working on! I'm debating between making a context trait and having the static function signature include a context instead of a request and the everything request related would be included/appended in the context, or having the user implement "controller" trait on their struct that has a method I will call after settling the routes (something like https://github.com/jroweboy/oxidize/blob/incoming/tmp/matchb... where maybe a macro can generate this method from the urls. Note that this code doesn't compile though :) While I was initially fond of the latter, it's been very painful to work with in practice and I don't see it actually working, so I think that I'll be testing out to see if I can rework the static functions to have a context. I think the hardest part is that I want to eliminate any need to have any static variables, but that means I have to store them all in a struct that requires Send to be fulfilled and thats more over head for programmers. In the near future, I will be looking into using the different parts of rust-http directly rather than implementing the server trait to see if I can gain any benefits from that :)

[mercurial]

Personally, I'd be inclined to have the context separate from the request, since they're really two different things. Also, you could introduce a FromRequest trait (trivially implemented by Request, returning self) to allow the user to build structures directly from a request (and its converse ToResponse), giving your function a signature of:

    fn (context: Context, req: FromRequest) -> ToResponse

    trait FromRequest {
      fn from_request<'a>(req: &'a Request) ->  &'a Self;
    }


    impl FromRequest for Request {
      fn from_request<'a>(req: &'a Request) ->  &'a Request {
        req
      }
    }

This would remove a lot of boilerplate for well-behaved applications. You'll also need a notion of middleware, which I guess would take a Request and return either a ToResponse or a request (eg, an authentication handler ought to return the response immediately in case of authentication failure), and similarly on the way out, something taking a Response and returning a Response.

[mercurial]

Ah, obviously this wouldn't work, from_request would need to return Self and not a reference for it work, which means some overhead in the case of Request, since you'd have to clone it.