Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by taeric 4437 days ago
I don't understand.

If both the .o and the .a are created from another file, wouldn't it be safe to just rely on either one of them? (Obviously, you will need to be consistent in choice.)

That is, if every time a .o is created, so is the .a, then where is the difficulty? Just rely on one (the .o). I could conceive of a scenario where the .a updated but the .o didn't, but I don't know of any tools that really work that way right now. I thought the norm was to at least touch all output files.

Further, if that is happening, seems you are safest having two rules, anyway.
1 comments
Someone 4437 days ago
Say you have a long build process and do a quick semi-clean by hand to speed up the next buld (not the best idea, but not inconceivable), deleting the .a files, but fogetting to delete the matching .o files. Then, your next build will produce some novel (to you) error messages that may take long to clean up. Worse, the command building on the .o and the .a might just say "OK, I'm given a .o without a .a; fine, then I'll do a slightly different thing"

Also, having two rules means duplicating a command:

    foo: foo.a
        baz $(BAZ_OPTIONS) foo

    foo: foo.o
        baz $(BAZ_OPTIONS) foo
That's bad from a maintenance perspective.
link
Too 4437 days ago
Invoking the command twice can also screw up things if you run parallel build, which you should always do! Not only to speed things up it's also a good way to verify that your make file actually is correct. If your make file doesn't work in parallel build it is broken, in the same way as C code that breaks at -O2 and above due to reliance on undefined behavior.

The solution to the multiple target problem is using the built in magic .INTERMEDIATE rule which isn't entirely obvious how it works.

link
taeric 4436 days ago
Ok, that makes sense. I'm tempted to rattle the knee jerk, "don't go deleting random crap," but I realize that is a hollow response.

I'm curious how .INTERMEDIATE helps in this case. I did find this link[1], which was a rather fun read down how one might go about solving this, along with all of the inherent problems.

[1] http://www.gnu.org/software/automake/manual/html_node/Multip...

link