Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by philtar 4459 days ago
There's no way email work like IM. You're missing the I part, instant.

Start two conversations on two different devices, one convo using email and the other using an IM program. Look at how fast they get out of sync.

2 comments

My mail clients have push support.

Look, I'm not saying 'Use mail for IM' nor do I claim that this is ideal. I'm saying that this is what I resort to because that's the _only_ thing that works.

In my world, there _is_ no IM solution. I don't have the necessary clients - or my friends don't. Or a subset of the people I want to reach are on a different service (Friend A & B on Hangout, C is using WA or Threema). The IM you talk about? It doesn't exist in my world and only therefor mail qualifies as 'as good as possible, given the environment'.

And .. if that makes 'IM' less like (each * a new message)

* Hi.

* You there?

* What are you doing?

* What about a beer tonight?

and leads to

"Hey, want to have a beer tonight?"

(still 'instant', as in 'reaches me in seconds and reply might! be equally fast) - all the better.

I don't think there's any technological reason why email should necessarily be slower than IM, that's something of an accident of history in the technology.