Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by MBlume 4466 days ago
The question is, what's going on if you do a stack-trace on why people find the joke funny. I think there's a certain amount of "haha, it says sex now" (same as with the [no sex cover](https://github.com/cmheisel/nose-xcover/) but I suspect there's at least some element of "sex change, that's gross and strange and weird, haha" which is pretty problematic.
2 comments

I think it's not "sex change Urgh weird and gross" but "sex change haha wow unpexpected".

A bit like PenIsland - or PenisLand. They get a lot of traffic from it.

I agree it is problematic if people are uncomfortable with the idea of gender reassignment and using that for humour. But then maybe that's a way those people use to get over those feelings of awkwardness and move to a place of acceptance?

I think it's a combination of the fact that our society has historically had a very perverse relationship with sex, in the sense that it is simultaneously icky, taboo and not to be talked about, yet also crucially important for brownie points and social cred.

However, the main reason is simply the fact that it's such a captivating example of unintentional humor, and what happens when you don't pay attention to your image. In many ways, it's the linguistic equivalent of the famous rabbit-duck optical illusion. It's curious and elicits a response when one realizes the double entendre.

It's hardly problematic, unless your definition of problematic is for everyone not to be dull as cardboard to every little example of unintentional humor in their lives.