Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JangoSteve 4503 days ago
Someone commented below (but their comment is dead, so I can't respond directly):

The Rails asset pipeline requires a JS runtime, so Broccoli doesn't have any more dependencies than asset pipeline in my mind.

Technically they're right that the Rails asset pipeline does require a JS runtime by default. But it's important to note that the Rails asset pipeline doesn't strictly require the JS runtime; it's only required for the coffee-script gem, which happens to be included by default for new Rails apps. If you're not using coffee-script for any of your assets, then no, it doesn't require a JS runtime.
1 comments
Wintamute 4503 days ago
But isn't Broccoli more of a frontend build tool? The primary motivation seems to be to speed up frontend development in terms of the save-file-build-wait-view-in-browser loop? I don't know much (anything) about the Rails asset pipeline, but isn't it used by the actual backend framework? As far as I can tell Broccoli is used to compile assets before the frontend files get anywhere near a backend ... so in this way its backend agnostic.
link
byroot 4503 days ago
Sprockets is a frontend build tool. It works basically the same way.

The main difference between sprockets and grunt / lineman / broccoli, is that sprockets do not watch files. It's a web application that compile your assets on the fly[0][1] when you need them.

So it's lazy, and blocking. Meaning that you do not have to guess if your assets have been recompiled yet. Your browser just ask for them, and get them as soon as they are ready.

[0] In development mode of course [1] In fact it cache the output, but whatever.

link
JangoSteve 4502 days ago
Bingo. But keep in mind that Sprockets doesn't have to be used just as a Rack server to compile on the fly, it can also be used to precompile to static files. In fact, you could then combine it with something like the watcher gem, and you now have automatic precompiling whenever you save your source files. In fact, there's the guard-sprockets gem which does all this for you [1].

[1] https://github.com/pferdefleisch/guard-sprockets

link