Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Turing_Machine 4542 days ago
At least 4/5 of the times it comes up in a Google search (for the stuff I search for, at least), some idiot moderator has closed the question.

The message that sends to me is "Your question isn't worthy of our site. Go away."

So, yeah, it does make using the site less pleasant, and thus reduces its value to me.

1 comments

Ditto. I stopped contributing to Stack Overflow because of this.

It's a classic example of cart-before-the-horse product thinking. Users aren't there to follow your orders; they're people with actual needs that you're trying to serve. I get that they don't want the site to be overrun with goofy content, because that prevents you from serving other actual needs. But there are better solutions than tasking a large number of people with running around and jerkily stomping out anything that doesn't fit the owners' precise vision.

I think this is the exact mistake that Friendster made. And really, the same one Google Plus made. Neither of those products were built for the users; they were built to serve the owners' desires.

Yes, the same with Wikipedia. The site has largely been taken over by people who are there simply to "be moderators".
And I see we have plenty of 'em here, too.