[waps]

Problems :

1) How do you get at the value itself ? (Casting ? That's bad)

2) How do you prevent in Maybe<Integer> x; x == null ?

3) How do you prevent someone from extending Maybe<T> ? e.g.

    public final class LetsHaveFun<T> implements Maybe<T> {
      public boolean hasValue() { throw Exception("Can't touch this");
    }

4) (you need a null check in the constructor)

5) (I dislike the autoboxing this uses)

[twic]

> 1) How do you get at the value itself ? (Casting ? That's bad)

You could add the usual map method to the Maybe type - a Maybe<T> can take a Function<T, U>, and returns a Maybe<U>. If it's None, it doesn't call the function, and just returns None; if it's Some, it calls it with the value, and wraps the result in a new Some. If you want to do side-effects conditionally on whether the value is there, you just do them in the Function and return some placeholder value. You could write a trivial adaptor to take an Effect<T> and convert to to a Function<T, Void>, etc.

> 2) How do you prevent in Maybe<Integer> x; x == null ?

You're right that using a Maybe does not exclude the ability to use nulls. Nobody can deny that. The point i was making is that there is nothing useful that you can do with nulls that you cannot do with a Maybe instead.

> 3) How do you prevent someone from extending Maybe<T> ? e.g.

You can trivially control extension by making Maybe an abstract class, giving it a private constructor, and making Some and None static inner classes of it. It's a kludge, but it works!

[anon4]

1) Yes, casting. You need to do casting in Haskell too, it's just hidden for you by pattern-matching

2) It's for a hypothetical Java implementation that doesn't have null

3) If you really want to, make it an abstract class and do a check in the constructor that this.getClass() == Nothing.class or Just.class.

4) see 2)

5) well if you're using primitive types they are non-nullable already

Edit: to clarify, I don't expect someone to use it for Java today, it's what I would put in the standard library if Java didn't have a null in the first place.