[surlyadopter]

I find Ardbeg (at least the Uigeadail) to be far smokier than Laphroig. The Lagavulin as well. To me the Talisker is quite bland, the sherry flavor really drowned out any peatiness.

[EpicEng]

Agreed. I love the Talisker Storm, but I have a Lagavulin 16 in my hand right now that gives it a run for it's money. Definitely more punch in the smoke and peat departments.

[nsns]

The elements effecting the taste of a Whiskey are mind-bogglingly complex, e.g. - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O_aLgTRQjmM&t=10m21s

[EpicEng]

I know, and I love Ralfy's reviews. Can't say my palette is up to his level, but luckily, practicing is fun.

[Bootvis]

Thoroughly enjoyed the Talisker 12. Plenty of peatiness there. I recently got a bottle Uigeadail and I might prefer the Talisker which is also cheaper.