[seanalltogether]

"There is no infringement in providing access in a good-faith belief that the content is legit."

I don't believe that is true. Content distribution is a complicated affair. Redistribution of content is not as easy as saying "well if site xyz has the right to distribute it, so do I"

[maxerickson]

The argument also hinges on the idea that the operator has "good-faith belief that the content is legit".

Stating that you have this good faith belief is not actually the same thing as having it.

[coldtea]

Not to mention that even having it doesn't mean anything at all.

Or, well, it make not make it "willingly infringement", but it still makes it infringement.