Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gress 4566 days ago
Depression is also rising to epidemic proportions, suggesting that improving economic indicators may simply not have anything to do with quality of life.
4 comments

GDP in particular has some huge problems as a measure of economic good.

There are numerous alternative measures which have been proposed, though none have been widely adopted: FISH, GPI, UNHDI, GSDP, GESDI, etc.

"Nobel Laureate: Examine Alternatives to GDP"

http://www.scientificamerican.com/podcast/episode.cfm?id=nob...

More like, mental health is not directly correlated with quality of life. Freed from the preoccupation of having to fight or work hard for basic needs, many people fail to find meaning in their life.
Are you seriously suggesting that there are more incidences of mental health issues because people have easier lives?
Why does that seem implausible?
Because a life of mental illness is not easy.
But an easy life can make one neurotic.
How?
Poor mental health = a low quality of life
Measuring averages from the extreme is not-accurate(via Taleb)
What has that got to do with anything that has been said?
I would probably be inclined to agree with that. From a report I read recently (which I can't find again, sorry) pertaining to my home town of Memphis, TN, apparently the general conclusion was that Memphians were happier than Nashvillians, despite the latter having better access to health care, better access to higher paying jobs, better community features (arts, entertainment, etc.)

The report didn't postulate on what the actual cause might have been, or how happiness was measured (or, if it was, I've forgotten), but I found it interesting, and it does support your point here. It seems that, at least since I've been paying attention, America has been trying to optimize for wealth or income, though statistically, it seems that there is validity to the notion that money doesn't buy happiness. If we could better isolate the causes of happiness, we could start optimizing for those factors instead.

Nashvillians don't want to be happy or else many wouldn't be able to effectively do their jobs of writing and performing country music.
Eh. That argument cuts both ways. Memphis blues aren't quite as big a deal as Nashville country, but it exists, and, on paper at least, should make musicians wont to sadness.