[coldtea]

>reads a lot like the Blub conceit

Perhaps. But then again the "Blub conceit" is nothing that exists in real life as a proven fact of computer science.

It's just an argument expressed in an essay. Not some kind of formal logical error.

[smosher]

What's your point?

[coldtea]

My point, which is pretty obvious, is that it "reading like the Blub conceit" doesn't mean anything at all with regards to its correctness.

Might as well say "your argument reads a lot as something that an unbeliever in the flying spaghetti monster would say".