Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by vinceguidry 4588 days ago
Please don't do a serious website without a container div limiting the width of the reading area. Most people with laptops keep their browser windows maximized, and resizing the window just to read one article is a huge pain in the ass. I usually just decide not to bother. Otherwise that website's great.
2 comments
teddyh 4588 days ago
Well, maybe they shouldn’t do that, then. If they don’t want a web site that wide, they shouldn’t make the web browser window that wide.

(Oh, I forgot that the web browser is not an application, but a platform and an OS in its own right, and has replaced the native OS. Silly me.)

link
vinceguidry 4588 days ago
One day you nerds will realize that technology serves people, not the other way around. I can't wait for that day.
link
maxerickson 4588 days ago
Are you talking about the web browser or the web page here? Or maybe the OS/DE that makes it awkward to split the screen/size the window to reading width?

Or the laptop, with it's silly form factor?

But sure, everyone that publishes some text better make sure they account for every context that it might get viewed in.

In the spirit of offering solutions, here's some code you can use to add a 'Narrow' button to your browser:

https://gist.github.com/maxerickson/7771860

link
vinceguidry 4588 days ago
I'm talking about a simple container div. Works everywhere.
link
maxerickson 4588 days ago
Yes, I understood you.

I thought it was bizarre that you thought having every author of a webpage put some noise in their code was the right place to fix your technology stack.

link
vinceguidry 4588 days ago
It's not noise, it's presentation markup. That's what HTML/CSS is for. To manage the presentation of information. It's not that hard. Learn a little responsive CSS and have the div go away if the browser's width drops below, say, 600px.

Visual presentation is a hard problem, has been ever since the tele-type days. You're always going to need some "noise". I'm not saying you have to go full-hog with design bling, but you should at least learn enough about responsive CSS so that your site is usable across the three main types of screen it will be displayed on.

link
dllthomas 4588 days ago
Is there some third way? Occasionally I really want it that wide, and if there's a div there's no way (short of firebug or grease monkey) to get it. At the same time, as someone who quite frequently has windows maximized, I feel some of your pain - though "ctrl-f S <read> ctrl-f Q" isn't exactly a "huge pain in the ass".
link