Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mnsc 4596 days ago
And the risk is they'll get inspired and try to solve another problem with css and a "clever declarative implementation" only that is better solved with the appropriate technology.

I'm not saying these tech explorations are bad, they just need to have a big fat disclaimer "don't try this in prod" and preferably a reference implementation of how it would be done "properly".
2 comments
crisnoble 4596 days ago
You certainly can and should use the underlying concepts, keyframes and pseudo content "in prod". You could use this stopwatch as well. Why not? It all depends on what you are trying to accomplish.

If everyone is worried that the tech is too scary or unstable or "wrong" TM, then we will never push the web forward into new territory. Remember when all form submissions forced a page refresh? If people were too afraid of front-end validation and AJAX calls then this would still be the reality.

link
corresation 4596 days ago
and preferably a reference implementation of how it would be done "properly"

Any implementation could be torn to shreds.

Because that's how the evolutionary, competitive nature of technology works. Nothing is "right" or "wrong", to use the scarequotes so in fashion, but is from a perspective and position. If things needed disclaimers around here -- as if we're all idiots, or worse jaded cynics -- then I think it would be a bad day for HN.

link
mnsc 4596 days ago
The disclaimer wasn't for the HN crowd necessarily. And the reference implementation would be useful for both showing "the proper way" and acting like a contrasting view. I don't understand animating with css so I would love to see "this is how you would accomplish the same thing using javascript", which I (without understanding css animation) believe is the right tool.

But of course, houndres of insane trick-focused css gurus churning out millions of crazy tech demos... Surely someone will find out some novel, more useful technique that we conservative programmers will begin to use for making the boring shit we do less burdensome. So I'm all for it really, despite my initial negative tone.

link