Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sjtrny 4620 days ago
The hard part about this problem is getting the scale and thus volume of the objects right. How big is that bowl holding your cereal?
3 comments

And is that Coke or Diet Coke?
And have you "hidden" a dash of syrup or 100g of nuts under the milk.

But it'd be useful for rough estimates for things like restaurant meals, with the aid of a menu.

panorama-like shot + obligatory 'token' in the shot should solve that, right?
Do the same as humans do : it's 25cl ... point. You won't be far off the mark.
You probably will be far off the mark. I realized once I started tracking my food seriously that 1) those glasses I have that I though were substantially bigger than those other glasses? They held the exact same amount; 2) the amount of calories I consume could easily vary by 30% or more depending on how full I'd fill my various glasses, plates or food containers.
I don't think getting a 30% margin of error would be all that disastrous. How big is the error margin on people measuring ?
A 30% margin of error would seem to make calorie counting practically useless.
I seriously doubt anyone doing calorie tracking without scales achieves less than a 30% error rate.