Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Nursie 4618 days ago
>>if people were more involved in their society

I think I see the flaw in your plan...

Most folks would rather delegate AFAICT.

3 comments

They would indeed rather delegate governance, and for the best of reasons; the more effort an individual is required to expend on governing, the less she has available to pursue her own talents and interests.

As for the respondents suggesting the answer is, in paraphrase, to "make governance interesting again" -- I would suggest they may wish to think twice about that superficially appealing suggestion. The process of governance was "interesting" in 1950s China, in 1930s Germany, 1920s Russia, the United States around 1925-1945; while conditions were vastly different in each case, of course, there is a strong common thread, and it is simply this: the process of governance is interesting only when times are not good; indeed, the worse things are, the more interesting the task of running the show tends to be. The argument eventually reduces to a suggestion that it would be nice to have a disaster or two around the place, in order to liven things up for everyone. Which it would, no doubt! But I submit such excitement is hardly worth the cost.

And that might be because politics seem distant, irrelevant, unalterable and (maybe as a result of this) plain boring. If politics and power became more decentralized, perhaps it would become more relevant and engaging to people.
Or maybe it could just be that we've had a taste of politics in our private lives, and decided we would much rather spend our time coding.
I believe that if people feel they can make a difference, people will get involved. If generally people can't make a difference, like today, people get apathetic.
I agree more might get involved but I'm less than convinced it would be enough to stave off the accumulation of power by warlords etc, and the eventual degeneration to a neo-feudal society.

But it's all just opinion at this end of the debate.

A decentralised society doesn't mean an unorganised society though.