Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by yOutely 4648 days ago
This is an ironic project because the Vim docs are one of the worst places to go for Vim help, partly due to their size and unsearchability.
1 comments

    :h 'option'
    :h :command
    :h i_ctrl-w
    :h ctrl-w
    :h v:
    :help auto<Tab>
    :help <C-d>
    :helpgrep foo | cw

    <C-]> on an highlighted word to jump to its doc
    <C-t> to jump back
The vim documentation is the best place to go for Vim help and it's on your computer.

Its size is a direct consequence of its completeness and its "unsearchability" is a direct consequence of the ignorance and possible unwillingness to learn of those who can't find their way.

Let's look up help on how to write a function

:h function

Ok, that's wrong.

Let's look up vimscript then, that probably has function information

:h vimscript

Nope, that's not what we want. But obviously function is further down the list

/function

Oh dear.

Let's say we want to do something on opening a python file, and we see someone else using Bufenter

:h bufenter

Ok, no usage examples. What to do?

Eventually we find out about autocmd, by luck. What if we want to include multiple statements in an autocmd?

:h autocmd

Nothing

/multiple

Nothing

Let's say (when you get lucky, again) and find out about :cmd1 | cmd2, you want to learn about |

:h |

nope

:h pipe

not even close!

Ooooooooooh maybe we have to escape it?

:h \|

what?

ooooh wait, we're in command mode, DUH

:h :pipe

aw, shit.

Maybe we want to split an array in vimscript.

:h split

Nope.

:h arary

Nothing. Maybe it's a list?

:h list

Nope. No splitting today, I guess.

If you think :h i_ctrl-w is intuitive, then, well. Have you ever been treated for schizophrenia or psychosis?

Let's say on entering a ruby file we want to press enter.

:au bufenter *.rb <cr>

open rb file..

trailing characters: <cr>

Oh god what the shit?

:h bufenter

nothing

:h ... it's now impossible to look up help on this problem. It's also impossible to google for it

We want to change the background color

:h background

Uhhhhh

:h color

Ok, I get it, I'm not going to find help on this. Time to give up.

I want to figure out how to set guicursor

:h guicursor

Are you 98% serious right now? Why are the examples using :highlight Cursor? Jesus.

Vim has horrible help. I will wait patiently for you to upvote my answer as opposed to downvote it, and I'll consider us even.

"writing a function"

    :help
    (scroll a bit)
    (find "usr_41.txt Write a Vim script")
    <C-]>
    (read)
"learn about |"

    :h :|
"split an array in vimscript" (what does that mean? "splitting a string into an array" or… something else?)

    :h split() or if that's not what you want,
    :h list-functions
:h i_ctrl-w is not intuitive when you start Vim for the first time but:

1. it is easy to understand how it works and apply that to subsequent searches,

2. it is indicated in the first screen of :help.

So yeah, after using that search query once, it is very intuitive. Schizophrenia != intelligence + curiosity.

"Let's say on entering a ruby file we want to press enter"

    :h autocmd
    (reading)
    autocmd BufEnter *.rb <CR>
    (doesn't work)
    (thinking)
    (oh! <CR> should be a normal mode command of course!)
    autocmd BufEnter *.rb normal <CR>
    (doesn't work)
    (oh! I remember, :normal only accepts ^M!)
    autocmd BufEnter *.rb normal ^M
"change the background color"

    (look at how it's done in a random colorscheme)
    :hi Normal guibg=#0066ff
"how to set guicursor"

    :h guicursor
What do you want to do with your guicursor if not setting its color and/or shape and/or blinking behavior? Everything is right there.

Vim has a large documentation that you learn to use little by little, query after query but all your examples assume no prior experience with Vim's :help

Impatience leads nowhere.

---

By the way I never downvote anything: I upvote to express my agreement and I answer to express my disagreement. That, and I don't have downward triangles anyway, a consequence of my presumably low "karma", maybe?