Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by drbawb 4665 days ago
The only Q&A I can recall before StackOverflow was finding answers on a message board _or_ finding the answers hidden behind a pay-wall. (e.g: ExpertsExchange, which I believe has been around since the 90s.)

StackOverflow was definitely a game-changer.
1 comments
ccozan 4665 days ago
the EE answers were never really behind a paywall, simply they were so hidden at the bottom of the page that a normal user did had the idea to scroll fully. After all, they needed to present the information to the google bot.
link
Shog9 4665 days ago
Did you ever try passing one of those links to a colleague? They were doing some referrer-checking at one point - if you weren't coming from Google, you didn't get the answer.
link
JTon 4665 days ago
Oh really, I had no idea they were doing this. Any idea why?
link
sp332 4665 days ago
They did that for a while, but Google implemented a policy that what gets shown to the Googlebot has to be the same as what a user would actually see. EE got delisted from Google for violating that policy, and ever since then, they have the answer way at the bottom of the page no matter what.
link
garethadams 4665 days ago
Actually, no.

Click through to this recently answered question from Google's search results[1] and scroll down to see the answer. Then open the resulting link[2] in an incognito tab and poof no answer

[1]: https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=experts+exchange+%22Troubl...

[2]: http://www.experts-exchange.com/Programming/Languages/Script...

link
slig 4665 days ago
Too bad Google doesn't care anymore, or else they'd do the same to Quora.
link
criley2 4665 days ago
Can we finally start calling Quora the spiritual successor to Experts Exchange?

Because it is.

link
alecsmart1 4665 days ago
Just put ?share=1 at the end of any Quora link to view the full page without any login.
link
hrasyid 4665 days ago
Quora contents tend to have bad search engine ranking, so probably Google still cares about that
link
dspillett 4665 days ago
That had been Google's policy for some time, they just started enforcing it for a while. IIRC it was around the same time BMW and a couple of other big names were temporarily de-listed for keyword stuffing and similar shenanigans.
link
rmc 4665 days ago
Why did they do that? To make the site less useful unless you'd paid up. i.e. "to encourage you to pay".
link
Hovertruck 4665 days ago
Because Google wouldn't list them unless clicking the link revealed the answer, I believe.
link