Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Zev 6237 days ago
Why use a dmg instead of a Zip? See Apple's docs, http://developer.apple.com/documentation/developertools/Conc...

Also, you could have taken 30 seconds in the past 5 years to explain to your uncle how to install Mac apps. Instead of, you know, ranting about how its convoluted the entire time. All you have to do is say "Double click it and drag and drop the file to /Applications." — Though thats irrelevant now, since Safari now handles dmg's with a .app the same as if it would when extracting a zip.

2 comments

Gee, what a great idea. I've explained a hundred times. It doesn't stick.

An icon comes up, and people click on it. It's natural and there is no indication of what you've done wrong. Then later, they have no idea where the app went.

DMGs serve no practical purpose. They are confusing to new users, and wasted clicks for power users.

Btw, that apple link you pasted shows no such reason to use a DMG over a zip.

If I missed it, please explain.

Also funny how so many developers provide zipped dmgs.