Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ivancdg 4698 days ago
This brings up an interesting question: if Steinway were liquidated, would the patents be up for sale?

It is my understanding that much of their unique quality comes from over 100 patents, many of which are over 100 years old [1].

Presumably a competitor could buy the patents and make significant improvements to their design.

Part of the Steinway brand is built on tremendous marketing savvy, generation after generation. But the technology remains unparalleled. As a professional pianist, I wouldn't use anything else for a recording.

Don't get me wrong, I would love for Yamaha, Fazioli or the others to make the market more competitive. But nothing compares to a Steinway in terms of sound quality and balance throughout the registers.

All the first-class piano technicians I know agree.

[1] http://www.ilovesteinway.com/steinway/parts/steinway_patents...

Edit: IvyMike and ryanhuff brought my attention to the 20 year maximum term of patent. It is surprising that Steinway's competitors still are unable to match the quality of sound. Perhaps their technicians are better?

3 comments

> over 100 patents, many of which are over 100 years old

Isn't the maximum "term of patent" 20 years or less?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Term_of_patent

In the US, patents expire after 20 years, so I doubt that patents have much to do with Steinway's value in today's market. (IANAL)
> Edit: IvyMike and ryanhuff brought my attention to the 20 year maximum term of patent. It is surprising that Steinway's competitors still are unable to match the quality of sound.

Not necessarily. Patents only need to describe enough to be enforceable, they don't have to include any of the subtle details which are necessary to make things tick. A famous example of this was all the patents filed by the famous German pharmaceutical & chemical giants in the USA to protect their cutting-edge processes: the patents worked very well to protect their IP, and then WWI came and the salivating competitors got the German patents seized - and couldn't figure out how to do the things, because the patents had left out critical details.