Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by roboneal 4694 days ago
I think you missed the rather insightful point he was making entirely.

The DEA's use of NSA intercepts "sounds" a whole lot more sensible (catching 'drug dealers') than what may be potentially 1000s of other horrific uses the government is also using this data for.
1 comments
tptacek 4694 days ago
It absolutely does not sound more sensible for the USG to be focusing the tools of foreign intelligence on its own citizens for drug enforcement. I didn't miss his point; his point is wrong. Using foreign intelligence for criminal justice does the opposite of legitimizing foreign intelligence programs.
link
samstave 4694 days ago
Where are you getting "foreign intelligence" from, not only in the article - but in relation to what I am talking about?

>a DEA supervisor intervened and revealed that the tip had actually come through the SOD and from an NSA intercept.

So how is my point wrong? This is trying to prove that the secret use of NSA data to catch baddies is an important function of the program.

link
tptacek 4694 days ago
Important? Maybe. Legitimate? No. Legitim-izing? Absolutely not. Today's revelations make the NSA's programs even less legitimate.
link