Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jfb 4707 days ago
Apple already sells a Thunderbolt docking station, with a very nice 27" display built in.
2 comments

Personally I think baking the GPU power into the displays themselves is the more Apple-y approach. As opposed to some sort of additional-stackable-boxes solution.

(Which I'd love to see; I just don't see Apple doing it.)

> Personally I think baking the GPU power into the displays themselves is the more Apple-y approach.

I don't agree.

Any Monitor with built in GPU won't make sense with the new Mac Pro, which (I think) will be the driving force for the new (likely 4K) Thunderbolt cinema displays.

But without the GPU what Apple machines other than Mac Pros will decently drive a 4k display? [1]

Apple's left the Pro line to languish for so long, I can't imagine they'd let it limit their ability to differentiate in the larger display business.

[1] And of those upgraded MBPs that could hit 4k aren't going to be able to do it on two displays, which is quite popular.

GPUs become obsolete way faster than monitors.
Are you trying to say Apple wouldn't put GPUs in displays because it might accelerate the display upgrade cycle?
I'm trying to say that customers aren't quite stupid enough to invest in a display that they'll throw out 18 months later.
In a product line-up where a new GPU requires an entire new machine, merely having to replace a display would actually be an improvement.

Not that people with those sorts of interests, even when Apple customers, rely on Apple hardware to serve those interests.

As long as it can be used with a pass-through Thunderbolt mode, it would still be perfectly usable as a display/port expander without using the internal GPU, should you buy a faster machine.

Also, Apple stuff seems to last damn near forever, so it'll hold a lot of resale value (even if the GPU is two years old) for those who want to upgrade.

It would be great if that docking station optionally included an awesome GPU. In the mean time, daisy chaining something like this on to the back looks very interesting.