Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ra 4710 days ago
Memory is not secure. It's quite a common attack to grab keys / passwords from the memory of an executing program.
1 comments

No, it is one of the safest places.

If your attacker has access to arbitrary memory of a process, you're using an insecure OS/version. Or they dumped your process memory using a vulnerability (in your system)

Yes, there are some possible attacks (page file, cache, etc)

Attacking memory after a reboot requires physical access (unless you hibernated without an encrypted file, in this case...)

It certainly beats the security of file/network

Just because it's more secure than network / file doesn't mean it's secure. That's why we have smartcards / HSMs.
Smartcards are vulnerable as well and there has been successful attacks towards some smartcards (google it)

And not every system has an HSM available

Sure but smartcards and HSMs are slow and in a properly managed environment are much safer than memory.

Whether or not the OP has an HSM is moot. The OP said, "I want to design and implement a solution as secure as it can be" ... and that means (among many other things) keys on HSM.