Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lmm 4723 days ago
"Matt Hofstadt wanted to make your day so Matt sent you..." is uglier and less pleasant to read than the version with "they've". I don't see any argument in the article for what's actually wrong with using "they" - sure, it violates one of English's alleged rules, but the author acknowledges that those rules don't actually matter.

(Personally I think women should insist on being called "he" - "she" is a grammatical diminutive which implies inferiority - but given that they haven't, singular they is the best approach available).

2 comments

"she" is a grammatical diminutive which implies inferiority

No it isn't. No it doesn't! Where'd you get that from?

(I'm a woman and I really would rather not textually eradicate my gender, thank you very much.)
"poetess" has been more or less eliminated from the language, and "actress" and "policewoman" are on their way out - at the behest of feminist groups. So it seems your compatriots disagree with you?