Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by patrickaljord 4716 days ago
> It's their and their citizens' prerogative.

No it's not. Our states are not pure democracies. If a majority of people decide by referendum that we should kill all Arabs, it would not be their "prerogative". That's because we are constitutional republics before being democracies. That is to say we all have to abide by what our constitutions say no matter what the majority say. And last time I checked, our constitution protects private and individual property. Therefor, a 75% tax or even 50% like we have in France goes against the protection of private property in our constitution and it was rejected by the supreme court here. Any taxation goes against the very basis of our constitutions and therefor should not be treated lightly or abused. Or do you think that if a majority decides it's ok to tax people 100% then that's ok because it's "their prerogative"? How about if a majority decide women shouldn't vote anymore either, would it be their prerogative too? The answer is no. Google and Amazon already pay lots of taxes in the US, if they had to pay in every single country, they'd have much less money to invest in all those products we enjoy while the government would just create more debt.