[sbierwagen]

He's talking more about Windows Phone, the Windows 8 apps, and Xbox.

[bornhuetter]

Is Windows Phone more of a walled garden than than iOS? Is the Xbox more of a walled garden than the Wii U? The argument is still complete hyperbole.

[AndrewDucker]

Windows Phone is more of a walled garden than Android.

[bornhuetter]

"bigger walled garden than Android" I would agree with.

[ams6110]

Most phone users want walled gardens: it's hard to get lost in one.

[jabits]

Um, what was the question?

[iaskwhy]

Together they are.

[bornhuetter]

I'm not sure I understand your point - can you please elaborate?

[iaskwhy]

Together Windows, Windows Phone and Xbox are the "biggest walled garden on earth".

[gtirloni]

When you add "Windows" there it completely dillutes the argument because Windows on the desktop is far from a walled garden as a proprietary platform can be.

[podperson]

Those may be walled gardens, but they're not very big.

[venomsnake]

XBOX commands sizable chunk of a very lucrative market. If we have luck the console industry will implode soon because the current model is unsustainable, but at the moment XBOX is not not very big.