[srik1234]

Apple is absolutely wrong with Most Favored clause. Even if they did not conspire with publishers directly, publishers effectively had the same opportunity and re-did their contracts with Amazon. The most concerning thing is that current law is granting amazon an unequivocal monopoly status. Lossleader strategy is employed to the extreme by amazon. Laws need to address that. At some point Amazon will raise prices. Current situation is essentially a loss for consumers and publishing industry.

[fpgeek]

There are plenty of other companies that can check Amazon. Consider Google. They make they can easily out-discount Amazon, they're also cross-platform and... and now that the Google Books scanning cases are turning in their favor they may soon have an huge new asset Amazon (and others) will have some trouble matching or beating.

[srik1234]

I'm sure other cash rich companies can mimic amazon strategy. Apple,google, microsoft, samsung certainly can. That is not good for industry though. Startups will have unbelievably tough time competing with Amazon. I cant remember any startup in recent times that ventured into ebook sales. Innvoation from other startups in ebooks creation, consumption is hard to come by, when amazon is playing a lossleader strategy forever.

[fpgeek]

First, no one has proven that Amazon was ever playing a true loss-leader strategy in ebooks, as opposed to losing money on bestsellers and making it up on the backlist.

Second, the existing DoJ settlement specifically allows publishers to police this. One of the terms the settling publishers are allowed to insist on is "no losing money on my catalog overall". That's more than enough to prevent truly anti-competitive discounting.

Third, yes, startups will have a hard time. But they had a hard time with the agency model too - which restricted their maneuvering room in significant ways. For instance, with a publisher-specified price you weren't just forbidden from charging "too little", you couldn't charge "too much" either. That means models where startups charged a premium for ebooks in order to support other services their target readers wanted were no longer possible.