Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dchest 4734 days ago
Could we also stop using silly scrolling hacks like here http://www.apple.com/mac-pro/, please? Thanks!
4 comments

To be honest, that's one of the worst implementations I've seen of that effect. Personally, I'm a fan of it when it's well done. Here's one example:

https://www.airbnb.com/annual/

imho that irritates me more than the mac one since it's information and the mac one is a product review so the scrolling kind of gives you a way to get a feel for the product. Although it does have a working scroll bar which the mac one lack.

On any of these how the hell am I supposed to navigate to a specific topic? or link any one to a specific point. The mac one does have tiny dots on the side. I think many people wouldn't even notice them.

The entire scroll hack just seems like a gimmicky, non-intuitive, time consuming alternative to using a slider to forward though a animation/video or some kind of navigation buttons with an animated transition. Or just play a regular movie/animation.

Only when Apple stops doing it I'm guessing.

ducks

I'm actually quite surprised they went with this. Maybe it tested well on touch surfaces...

It didn't even work for me. Scrolling, clicking... nothing causes anything to change. The scrollbar in Chrome is missing.
It's incredibly buggy for me - chrome on windows. Even when it allowed me to scroll, it was slow and jerky. I suspect it's designed for the acceleration based scrolling on mac touchpads however, so I'm not too surprised that the scrollwheel on my mouse disagreed with it.
Apple.com does not work well on chrome. It hasn't for years.
hell yeah, carousels/sliders are harmless in comparison with these UX abominations...