Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Zigurd 4721 days ago
The NTSB wants to make forward collision avoidance systems in cars standard. I wonder if it would be possible to spoof radar and/or IR return signals so as to trip the autonomous braking in a car that gets too close to a bike?
4 comments

Try thinking more than one step at a time.

What will be the very next thing that happens if you actually succeed in doing this?

It would be made illegal immediately due to the potential for abuse.
Similar to how the emergency red-light-to-green traffic signal preemption devices were summarily banned in a lot of places after people figured out the very simple mechanism they use.

http://www.10news.com/news/driver-cited-for-using-traffic-li...

Hiding, as always, the original problem (cars not detecting bikes) would be unaddressed while a fake problem (people causing accidents) gets people's attentions via the msm.

Don't do this.

Cars would stop hitting bikes?
No, cars would disable this device because it is causing false positives.

And now a useful safety feature is no longer available.

Perhaps something as simple as having a little video camera on bikes would discourage drivers from getting too close. If lots of cyclists had them drivers might start to move over a little more. Just knowing that you might be recorded could be enough incentive to a avoid cyclists.
I thought about having a small flag on a really sharp antenna-style post sticking on the left side of the bike. About a foot or two, laying parallel to the ground should do. That would encourage drivers to give a bit more room, as they are probably more afraid of getting their car scratched up then they are of hitting someone.
That still does nothing about the distracted driver. They aren't going to see the flag if they're looking down at their phone laughing and writing a text.
I think there is a range of tools that would making biking safer. I saw a lighting system that outlined a "box" around the cyclist. Some kind of automatic horn/led-flasher that would activate if a car got too close might be of some value.
I half suspect that might be construed as some sort of terrorist activity/behaviour.
Perhaps cities should build bike lanes.
Mercedes have done a lot of work around this (more for pedestrians than cyclists I believe) for their S-Class: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7m9qI70L2yQ
I remember seeing on Top Gear a review of a car with a collision detection system that could detect pedestrians. (I think it was a Volvo.) I wouldn't be surprised if it also detects bicycles without active cooperation from the cyclist.
The company Autoliv has a bunch of such products, they're used by major car manufacturers.

See for instance http://www.autoliv.com/ProductsAndInnovations/ActiveSafetySy... which describes their "vision systems", the features of which include pedestrian-detection.

It's possible that Volvo has its own in-house tech for this, but Autoliv are huge.

Ah, of course I should have mentioned that Autoliv are not by any means alone in the market. :) Thanks.