Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dave1010uk 4747 days ago
Can anyone tell me how are HTML5 "extensions" different to or better than "plugins" (eg Flash, QuickTime, Silverlight)? Has the line between open browser / specification and proprietary plugins just been shifted over a bit?
2 comments
baddox 4747 days ago
The primary user-facing difference is that these "extensions" don't require additional installation to view content (that is, once all major browsers support them). From a technical perspective, there could other differences, like protections in place to sandbox the browser from the rest of the system, which is much better than requiring the execution of a closed-source proprietary binary.
link
dave1010uk 4747 days ago
So if Flash player was built into all major browsers (like it is currently with Chrome) then that would remove the primary reason.

I thought EME was execution of a closed-source binary blob too. I also thought some browsers sandbox plugins (I could be wrong).

EME still seems to be just a new plugin specification, with a more limited API.

link
quackerhacker 4747 days ago
The real benefit I see in regards to HTML5 video is mp4 streaming to xbox, chrome, safari, ie, firefox (on windows), android, and ios.

Utilizing other formats (like vp9, flash, and silverlight [silverlight I think is getting discontinued]) will cut off your ios demographic.

link