Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by agargarg 4743 days ago
But it wouldn't handle indentation properly, unless you define a standard formatting convention similar to Markdown. For example, you need to handle bullet points. But what if a plain, non-indented text just happens to contain a star at the start of a line? This means headaches for text writers to avoid these edge cases, and wrong indentation when viewing legacy texts.

Also, all viewers would have to support it, which somewhat defeats the purpose of using plain text.
1 comments
DanBC 4743 days ago
> But it wouldn't handle indentation properly

8 spaces is fine.

> For example, you need to handle bullet points.

Asterisks are fine.

> Also, all viewers would have to support it, which somewhat defeats the purpose of using plain text.

I think that you're over thinking what plain text is. I don't mean "plain text with some additions". I really do just mean plain text.

link
agargarg 4743 days ago
> 8 spaces is fine.

I'm not talking tab characters, I'm talking indentation of whole paragraphs with plain spaces, as seen in the article. Most existing viewers just wrap long lines so that the wrapped content is unindented: this makes any indentation hard to notice and mostly useless. For your proposition to be viable, viewing software has to detect indentation and keep that indentation in wrapped lines.

> Asterisks are fine.

Ok, but usually you want to indent the wrapped contents by 2 columns otherwise asterisks become hard to notice. This is only possible with special magic in the viewer.

link
agargarg 4743 days ago 

  --- BEGIN MESSAGE ---
  --- BEGIN BLOCK QUOTE ---
  --- BEGIN BLOCK QUOTE ---
  I'm not talking tab characters, I'm talking indentation of whole paragraphs
  with plain spaces, as seen in the article.
  --- END BLOCK QUOTE ---
  Ah, okay. You're right, indenting an entire paragraph is hard.
  --- BEGIN BLOCK QUOTE ---
  This is the kind of thing they'd do on Usenet.
  --- END BLOCK QUOTE ---
  --- END BLOCK QUOTE ---
  All you get is a very verbose markup language :-)
  --- END MESSAGE ---
link
DanBC 4743 days ago
> I'm not talking tab characters, I'm talking indentation of whole paragraphs with plain spaces, as seen in the article.

Ah, okay. You're right, indenting an entire paragraph is hard.

--- BEGIN BLOCK QUOTE ---

This is the kind of thing they'd do on Usenet.

---END BLOCK QUOTE ---

link
angersock 4743 days ago
Sometimes there is no replacement for just a big honking array of ASCII.
link