Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by andyhmltn 4747 days ago
Because I believe you aren't completely in control of the dog. Just like you aren't completely control of another human when using conversational techniques to make them do something.

You wouldn't be able to manipulate a dog into taking its own life, but with this cockroach you would against its will.

1 comments

It's pretty easy to make a whippet run into heavy traffic merely by throwing a ball.
I agree it is easy but are you the kind of person to kill a dog without any reason? This statement implies that it is ethical to do so.

The people behind this project say that it is for educational purposes, but really now.. how many people will use it that way?

I was answering the question whether or not it is possible to manipulate a dog to take it's own life. I think it is possible. I do not think it's ethical, though. However, it might be, if the dog was Cujo.
Great point. But there's a huge difference between throwing a ball that an animal chases and sending electrical impulses into its brain to physically make it run into the traffic.
Trust me, they'd run into traffic without the ball too.