Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by carbocation 4773 days ago
> Know there is much more to a meaningful life than health

Nicely said. There seems to be a pervasive notion among my classmates (yours too, I bet) that health is the most important value. I think people should and do decide which things they value most, and that top value is not always maximizing every aspect of health. There are tradeoffs to be made. (Otherwise, ahem, nobody would do residency.)

Health, by the way, is a constellation of different, related factors. Even within the overarching concept of "health," people hold these factors in different esteem.

1 comments

There's a nice Nietzsche quote about this:

"Even the determination of what is healthy for your body depends on your goal, your horizon, your energies, your impulses, your errors, and above all on the ideals and phantasms of your soul. Thus there are innumerable healths of the body; and the more we allow the unique and incomparable to raise its head again, and the more we abjure the dogma of the “equality of men,” the more must the concept of a normal health, along with a normal diet and the normal course of an illness, be abandoned by medical men. Only then would the time have come to reflect on health and illness of the soul, and to find the peculiar virtue of each man in the health of the soul."