[bruceboughton]

Great unless you're a home construction business.

Anyway, this analogy isn't helping anyone. You think libs in source control is a problem because some people might not do it properly. I'm contending that there's nothing wrong with libs in source control--there's something wrong with letting people who might not do it properly near your source control.

[mercurial]

There are clear benefits from having a package manager (if anything, pesky things like version numbers, direct dependencies, etc are self-documented). In addition, it does prevent people from taking shortcuts, and even good people take shortcuts when the deadline is short enough.