Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jessriedel 4807 days ago
Macroecon has the simultaneous hindrances of (1) not being able to run a controlled experiment and (2) a dearth of data. It doesn't excuse people for being far too confident in the conclusions they draw, but it does explain why such large differences of opinions can persist (especially on such a politically charged subject). People can't be pulled away from their priors.
1 comments
dragonwriter 4807 days ago
> Macroecon has the simultaneous hindrances of (1) not being able to run a controlled experiment and (2) a dearth of data.

Well, except #1 should be "not being able to run experiments in laboratory conditions". Statistical controls in an experiment are still controls, and it is still possible though (because of the point made briefly by #2, to run statistically-controlled experiments) sometimes of limited utility; the dearth of data (specifically, the small number of data points compared to the number of independent variables that need to be controlled for) is what limits the utility of many experiments with statistical controls in the field.

link
jacques_chester 4806 days ago
Even if you use rigorous statistical techniques -- and economists do under the heading of econometrics, even inventing new techniques -- it's still really hard to draw meaningful conclusions.

There are just so many variables. And the more interconnected the world becomes, the more variables there are. Pointing to any one correlation and you'll find a hundred statistical fingers pointing at correlations with totally different consequences.

link
dragonwriter 4806 days ago
> Even if you use rigorous statistical techniques -- and economists do under the heading of econometrics, even inventing new techniques -- it's still really hard to draw meaningful conclusions.

> There are just so many variables.

Right. That's the problem with too few data points given the number of independent variables that need to be controlled for. I addressed that explicitly.

link
pseut 4806 days ago
Political constraints and welfare concerns effectively rule out "controlled experiment" at the present time.
link
jessriedel 4807 days ago
Agreed.
link