Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mindcrime 4815 days ago
Interesting stuff. Personally I'm from the camp of people who don't put a lot of stock in credentials. I wouldn't go so far as to say they carry no weight, but I certainly don't weight them particularly heavily, especially if I have anything else whatsoever to go on.

And to the extent that I do care about, say, a college degree, I definitely am not of the mindset that "You have to have gone to an Ivy League school, or you're obviously a dolt who will never accomplish anything". In fact, I think recruiting at less prestigious schools could be a source of competitive advantage, especially for cash starved early-stage startups. Why try to compete with Google and IBM and Cisco and Microsoft, etc. for grads from Stanford, Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Columbia, Brown, MIT, etc., etc? Forget that, we will probably recruit at schools like North Carolina Central[1], Shaw[2], St. Augustines[3], Peace[4], Meredith[5], Wake Tech[6], Durham Tech[7], UNC-Pembroke[8], Fayetteville State University[9], NC A&T[10], Winston-Salem State[11], etc. There's talent to be had everywhere, and I doubt we'll be finding a lot of Google recruiters on those campuses.

[1]: http://www.nccu.edu/

[2]: http://www.shawu.edu/

[3]: http://www.st-aug.edu/

[4]: http://www.peace.edu/

[5]: http://www.meredith.edu/

[6]: http://www.waketech.edu

[7]: http://www.durhamtech.edu

[8]: http://www.uncp.edu/

[9]: http://www.uncfsu.edu/

[10]: http://www.ncat.edu/

[11]: http://www.wssu.edu/

2 comments

As for the Bay Area, I've consistently been impressed by Cal Poly SLO guys I've met.

Their education is so much more practical and real-world-ready than my Ivy League engineering education (which was largely theoretical in nature).

I mean, I have nothing against Ivy League schools, or their graduates. And I won't even say that I think they are overrated so much as I think other schools, and their graduates are underrated. I also think there are a lot of other factors that affect the extent to which someone is a valuable employee, beyond sheer academic ability. Attitude, work ethic, personality, ambition, perserverance, cultural fit, etc. Net-net, my personal belief is that a firm can hire recruiting largely from schools that are not the famous, elite "top tier" schools, and still hire plenty of smart, talented, successful people.

Maybe time will prove me wrong, but we'll see...

Are you hiring? I'm in your neck of the woods, looking for new opportunities, and your problem space looks interesting.
Sorta, not exactly, maybe. It's complicated. :-) Shoot me an email and we can chat... prhodes (at) fogbeam (dot) com