Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by crazygringo 4824 days ago
> Answers will be from real employees who show their names.

Honestly, that seems to kind of defeat the whole purpose, doesn't it?

I'm assuming that questions are all going to be more-or-less standard. The value is in the "ugly" but true answers (e.g. the product manager is an idiot and management is a disaster, and the product will implode within a year), which no employee would ever sign their name to.

So what kind of value is this site attempting to provide, in the end? Is it trying to simply be a database on workplaces? I don't really understand what having anonymous questions has to do with anything.

1 comments

It might be useful to get former employees opinions. I am sure rachelbythebay will give you unfiltered answers about what her experience was like with Google. Former employees jobs don't depend on toeing the line.
I would worry that this might open someone to a lawsuit, even an ex employee if they cannot be anonymous.

However with anonymity it would be very open to shilling.