Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by arethuza 4846 days ago
Don't those kinds of industrial research jobs also usually require the kind of publication track record that you have to acquire in academia to survice?

Do industrial research labs really employ freshly minted PhDs - who probably haven't acquired the most important skill in modern research: the politics of attracting funding/backing?
2 comments
seanmcdirmid 4846 days ago
> Don't those kinds of industrial research jobs also usually require the kind of publication track record that you have to acquire in academia to survice?

Yes.

> Do industrial research labs really employ freshly minted PhDs - who probably haven't acquired the most important skill in modern research: the politics of attracting funding/backing?

Yes. How do you expect freshly minted PhDs to learn the art of attracting funding and backing?

link
arethuza 4846 days ago
The black arts of attracting funding seems to be what junior academics spent considerable amounts of time doing when I worked in academia - mind you that is going back a bit so wouldn't surprise me if things have changed a lot.
link
seanmcdirmid 4846 days ago
Keep in mind parent was talking about industrial labs, where funding is obviously a bit different. I don't really know much about academia beyond what I hear from peers.
link
thomasjames 4846 days ago
It is actually very common to go to a research facility after a PhD. Anyone with a doctorate from a reputable program will have a list of publications that demonstrate a clearly defined interest and quite possibly even grants. For those that aren't at the level of a research scientist, there are often post-doctoral fellowships. If the companies are large enough, grants are less of an issue because there is a built-in R&D budget. There is less of the panhandling you see in academia.
link
arethuza 4846 days ago
I did know some colleagues who went to work for large corporates in research labs - but they seemed pretty rare in the UK. Most stayed in academia or left to work in finance - and some even left to found startups (like me!).

Out of interest, what are some examples of the "research facilities" you are talking about?

link
thomasjames 4846 days ago
IBM T.J. Watson, IBM Dublin, Oracle Labs, Google Mountain View, PARC Inc.,... there are some other ones that are more specific to HPC.
link