Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by KaeseEs 4837 days ago
I'm interested in what the accuracy, stability and precision of this barometer are. For the use case that they were put into that phone (and the price point it implies), I am unsure whether data reported from these phones will be useful for PressureNet.

Longer explanation: in the parlance used for pressure measurement, a barometer is a low-pressure absolute gauge (although what they pack in the phone is a sensor or transducer rather than a full gauge for obvious reasons). In order to measure absolute pressure, it needs to pack a good source of vacuum to be used as one of the differential inputs. And it needs to do it real small and real cheap. I suspect they're using a piezoresistive or capacitative sensor for this pressure range, which both have a significant tempco, and they almost certainly can't do a valid temp-comp on the part for cost reasons (you can sort of bullshit it by characterizing the lead unit and applying that to everything based on a curve fit, but the results are not great).

Sensors in this form factor and for this price point might be accurate to within +- 2.5%, which is not terribly useful for a barometer for weather purposes.

1 comments

Somebody posted a link to pressureNETs data:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5380672 http://pndv.cumulonimbus.ca/

If you zoom in on a location that has lots of people (say, New York City), you can see the readings moving together. That suggests some utility.