Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ctbeiser 4862 days ago
As a student, I'm just going to say that it's about time somebody did this. Even going to an extremely high-quality school, Salman Khan is just a better at explaining concepts than your teacher. And that's okay.

Just consider this: If students statewide are failing to understand a concept, new videos can be A/B tested in its place, and you put the winner into practice. You actually have the potential to optimize teaching, at high scale, for what helps people learn. That's a huge step forward for everyone involved.

2 comments

Students often work hardest for teachers they like or look-up-to or respect most. So for many students, explaining things well is one necessary but not sufficient teacher characteristic.

Your point is important, and needs to be made. We do need teacher who both understand and explain things well. But in most discussions on education, I am troubled by the lack of emphasis placed on the role teachers have in motivating students, and whether proximity will have an effect there.

When we look back on our school or college days, and think of our most influencial teachers, what stands out most?

The real problem is that no one teacher is "the best" for all students. What would be brilliant to see is testing which types of presentation styles, speakers or ways of explaining concepts resonate with individual students and giving them a personalised education, no matter which class they get put in each year.

A huge step forward indeed.