[dmishe]

I thinkg that tonsils is one of first line defenses against bacteria/infections, so removing them would be suboptimal, although necessary

[rdtsc]

The idea is that at some point they (being the first line) succumb to infection and can be come the site of a persistent infection that in turns causes more sore throats and re-infections.

At least that was my experience. I was advised to take them out in my mid 20's. It does seem that there is correlation, now that they are out I get less colds and sore throats.

[dmishe]

Were you advised because of some condition where it was clear tonsils was the problem, or just a routine operation?

[rdtsc]

Switched to a different doctor and went for a consultation. Complained about by frequent sore throats. He looked in and said, we should take these out. (This wasn't in US but in Europe)