Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by shrikant 4864 days ago
You're right, but this is a PR battle at this stage, and these are rarely known to be won on nuance and accuracy.
1 comments

Perhaps that's true for most people, but I expected more from both sides.
What more did you expect from the NY Times? They seem to be quite forthcoming and balanced.
Their reporter was busted for at best being sloppy and at worst lying to grind an axe against electric vehicles -- and they delivered a mealy mouthed half-admission of fault. A controversial, sensational story that isn't "unassailable" and was shown to be very questionable should have been withdrawn without mincing words. If they want to run the tests again under more rigorous circumstances, then they're free to do so.

We really should expect better from those with the job of giving us information.

A journalist who took better notes?