[pdenya]

Is generating a 4 color palette based of a random seed all it takes to be art? Not to say it wasn't worth executing from a personal standpoint, it was probably fun to build if nothing else, but really what possible use can anyone else get out of this?

[cormullion]

These days, 'art' is an almost meaningless term, since it has to include this:

http://www.tate.org.uk/art/artworks/creed-work-no-233-p78388

[quarterto]

Art is anything that someone somewhere could claim is not art.

[polarix]

Is anything that anyone claims as art.

[brianwillis]

The work’s irreverent message appears discreet due to its small size and almost apologetic lower-case lettering; the blank expanse of the rest of the page, however, gives the words disproportionate weight and presence. This simultaneously self-effacing and assertive quality is typical of Creed’s work.

I don't know where to begin. If I didn't know any better I'd think this was a parody.

[GuiA]

I was in the same boat as you; reading this shed some light:

http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/14y6fj/el...

[ezequiel-garzon]

You had me at "fu". Bookmarked!

And, on a more serious note, pretty depressing.

[barking]

Being depressed by this is a bit like being depressed by pop because you think only classical music is music. He's not stopping anyone from doing better art. I wouldn't be into his art particularly but neither am I into the sort of paintings you see in national galleries either. Really it wouldn't surprise me if he turned around one day and said the whole thing was a big joke. He practically does just that here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6syZr_me_Bg

[joshschreuder]

The question is, how do you get the the point in your career where you can put stuff like this and people laud it?

If I went to a gallery and offered this up I'd obviously be laughed out of the place.

[ezequiel-garzon]

Indeed, I only found depressing the fact that this "work" made it to a prestigious museum.

[ibudiallo]

Nowadays being alive is art.

[pcole]

We put this together one afternoon because it was fun and quick to do. We were looking into generating colours for our site and logo that would somehow be different for every visitor. We thought about this but then realised it wouldn't be that practical. If it can inspire someone to do something similar but more useful then that's enough for me :-)

[eksith]

Art is a means of expression, whether you can see meaning in it or whether it had any meaning at all or even if you think it wasn't particularly creative. Art serves no other purpose other than to be art. In that regard, yes, this can be considered art. I thought it was quite creative in a relatively unexplored medium, your IP, instead of oil paint.

And I vehemently disagree with cormullion's comment : http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5239734

Consider Malevich's work : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Malevich.black-square.jpg

Yes, that's in a museum. And it wasn't made "these days" either.

[colmvp]

Is putting a toilet in a gallery all it takes to be art?