Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nferiuernjkf 4881 days ago
Who did the what now???

  As investigators work to find the cause of the initiating
  short circuit, they ruled out both mechanical impact damage
  to the battery and external short circuiting.
Sounds to me like no orgin was identified at all. All they know is that the fire started because of short-circuiting. But what caused the short circuiting? I don't know?
1 comments
pdonis 4881 days ago
Read a bit further:

Chairman Hersman said that potential causes of the initiating short circuit currently being evaluated include battery charging, the design and construction of the battery, and the possibility of defects introduced during the manufacturing process.

They don't know the precise cause, but they have narrowed it down to a few possibilities.

link
grecy 4881 days ago
Chairman Hersman said that potential causes of the initiating short circuit currently being evaluated include battery charging, the design and construction of the battery, and the possibility of defects introduced during the manufacturing process.

Paraphrase:

"The thing we built doesn't work properly, and we think it could be because of how it works, how we designed it, or how we built it".

Sounds like a useful assessment.

link
HeyLaughingBoy 4881 days ago
Of course it's useful. It's just like debugging code: when the bug first surfaces, the cause can be anything in a large space. As you learn more of the characteristics of the bug, the problem space grows smaller until you eventually identify the root cause.

They've just learned what areas to focus on.

link
maaku 4881 days ago
"how it works, how we designed it, or how we built it" is pretty much inclusive of every possibility and doesn't rule anything out. In other words, useless.
link
pdonis 4881 days ago
The NTSB is not saying what you are claiming. They are only talking about those possibilities in reference to one specific failure mode: a short circuit in a single battery cell causing a fire that spreads through the entire battery. That rules out a lot.
link
pdonis 4881 days ago
Um, the NTSB didn't build the battery. The quote I gave is from the NTSB chairman, not from Boeing. She was talking about the current state of an ongoing investigation, which has already narrowed down the possibilties greatly.
link