Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bbx 4888 days ago
Oh, it's that Grey Period [1] all over again...

I loved the previous design [2]. It only used 2 fonts (and default ones, for that matter): Georgia and Arial. But it didn't feel 'cheap'. The font-size, letter-spacing, small-caps, weight and style variations provided a versatile set of text layout.

The spacing and colors were perfect too, and yielded a well-thought and pleasant visual hierarchy. It is one of the few websites I enjoyed reading directly from the website (instead of using Google Reader or Instapaper).

I'm sure many hours of work are behind that new design. And maybe it's the same for any redesign: I'll get used to it. But I'm not thrilled. We'll see.

[1]: http://jgthms.com/the-grey-period.html [2]: http://alistapart.com/d//368/jsm.png

2 comments

The Grey Period seems to be like Flat Design and Big Fonts: there's an unwelcome general trend at the moment to dumb everything down to the point of being... well, dumb.

Subtle visual effects like gradients and shadows and the use of different colours don't just make a site or UI look pretty, they also give cues about how it works. At the moment, it seems like everything is just another flat, grey rectangle, and we've reached the point where sometimes you literally can't tell whether something on the screen is a block quote, a button, the title of a drop down menu, or possibly even more than one thing arranged in a toolbar...

These new trends can't die fast enough, IMHO. Too many projects are sacrificing both usability and aesthetics just to be fashionable.

designers and users need to speak up about it , that trend is silly , horrible and i'm sick of it. Does it work on tablet ? maybe but it doesnt work at all on desktop, and they did not vanish obviously. The heck you dont even need designers anymore , there is no design at all on these website. flat , no texture , no balance , nothing ...
The font size used to be horrifically small. This is a big step up, for this change alone.
They fixed the too-small-font problem (finally!!) at the beginning of March last year, making it a very reasonable read, and without changing the overall design much.
I browse Hacker News at 200% zoom.