Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by betterunix 4903 days ago
How is disproportionate representation fair?
3 comments

> How is disproportionate representation fair?

Disproportionate representation is fair (only) if the criteria of discrimination is justifiable.

An obtuse example: Gifted & hardworking athletes are disproportionally over-represented at the olympics, vice gifted + lazy, non-gifted + lazy, and non-gifted + hardworking ones.

How is it fair to treat human beings as instances of abstract categories rather than as individuals who possess their own agency?
In either case, how is what the woman did with this conference a good thing? On the one hand, she categorized people as "male or female" and on the other she created a situation where there were a higher proportion of women speaking at the conference than were even in the field.
I suppose you are not talking about disproportionate representation of women in tech here?
No, I am talking about the disproportionate representation at the conference itself, because the field itself is what lacks diversity. Fix the diversity problem within the field, and if after that the conferences lack diversity, we can fix that problem too.